When Fethullah Gulen published his article on Financial Times, I was expecting a response from the infamous Islamophobes or those who happen to be in close connection with them. My prediction came true with the latter. Stephen Schwartz, who always seems to attack the mainstream Muslims in the U.S., published a incendiary and biased article in response to that of Mr. Gulen. Mr. Schwartz was mostly busy with attacking Mr. Gulen than criticizing the content of Mr. Gulen's article. He even brought that fallacious Gulen Charter Schools concept to the table again. Anyway, a timely and nice response came from Dr. Scott Alexander.
It is pretty ironic that Fethullah Gulen, a moderate Muslim, is defended by a Catholic, Dr. Alexander, and is attacked by a Muslim, Mr. Schwartz! You decide who is right. Here is Dr. Alexander's response:
I am puzzled by the fact that a man as seemingly intelligent and
articulate as Mr. Schwartz appears to have deliberately misread the
Op-Ed piece by Mr. Gülen. I say this because, in the very beginning of
Mr. Schwartz’s critique, he clearly demonstrates that he has no
intention of striving for even the least degree of objectivity and
fairness in his analysis of Gülen’s remarks. In fact, I am saddened to
say that what Mr. Schwartz attempts to offer as a trenchant critique of
Gülen and the global Gönüllüler Hareketi (“Volunteers’
Movement”) amounts to little more than a hatchet job on a religious
leader who has inspired thousands, perhaps millions, of men and women to
a reawakening of their faith and a faith-based commitment to service.
